IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA¶
CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, CASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB Publisher of THE PALM BEACH POST,¶
DIVISION: AG¶
Plaintiff,¶
v.¶
DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Beach County, Florida.¶
Defendants.¶
A Cos¶
c JOINT EXHIBIT¶
Plaintiff, CA Florida Holdings, LLC (“PI \ ikc• ), blisher of The Palm Beach Post, and Defendant, Dave Aronberg, as State Atto of 1FaIm Beach County, Florida (“Defendant”) (collectively, the “Parties”), by and dersigned counsel, and pursuant to the Court’s Order on Joint Motion to Con ntiary Hearing on Dave Aronberg’s Amended Motion for Attorneys’ Fees dated Au , 021, hereby submits the following list of joint exhibits that the Parties may rely upo dt ring the special-set evidentiary hearing scheduled on Tuesday, September 6, 0 p.m.:¶
| TRIAL JOI | IllithalES’ | |
|---|---|---|
| EX. NO. E | X REFS. | DATE DESCRIPTION NOS. CA/Aronberg-000001- |
| J0I | P01 | 08/27/19 Letter to D. Aronberg from S. Mendelsohn re: Public Records Request CA/Aronberg-000003 |
| J02 | P02 | 09/27/19 Letter to J. Pacenti from N. Cruz re: Public Records CA/Aronberg-000004 Request |
| J03 | P03 | 10/01/19 Letter to J. Musgrave from N. Cruz re: Public CA/Aronberg-000005 Records Request |
| J04 | D02, Ex. A-I | 11/14/19 Summons and Complaint CA/Aronberg-000008- CAJAronberg-000099 |
| TRIAL EX. NO. | JOINT EX. NO. | PARTIES’ EX. REFS. | DATE | DESCRIPTION | NOS. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J05 | P04; | ||||
| D01, Ex. G; | |||||
| D02, Ex. A-2 | 11/26/19 | Letter to J. Howard from D. Wyler re: confirmation of legal representation | CA/Aronberg-000100 | ||
| J06 | D02, Ex. A-3 | 12/06/19 | Motion to Dismiss | CA/Aronberg-000101- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000103 | |||||
| J07 | P05 | 12/16/19 | Motion for an Order Unsealing Grand Jury Testimony in State of Florida v. Epstein , Case No. 50-2006-CF-009454-A | CA/Aronberg-000104- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000109 | |||||
| J08 | P06 | 01/14/20 | Order Denying The State’s Motion for an Order Unsealing Grand Jury Testimony Without Prejudice in State of Florida v. Epstein , Case No. 50-2006-CF-009454-A | CA/Aronberg-000110- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000116 | |||||
| J09 | P07; | ||||
| D02, Ex. A-4 | 01/17/20 | First Amended Complaint | CA/Aronberg-000117- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000210 | |||||
| J10 | D02, Ex. A-5 | 01/24/20 | Defendant, Dave Aronberg, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida’s Answer to First Amended Complaint and Motion to Dismiss Count II | CA/Aronberg-000211- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000223 | |||||
| J11 | D05 | 01/30/20 | Defendant Aronberg Twitter Post | CA/Aronberg-000224- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000225 | |||||
| J12 | D06 | 01/30/20 | SAO15 Press Release | CA/Aronberg-000226 | |
| J13 | P08; | ||||
| D02, Ex. A-6 | 06/03/20 | Hearing Transcript | CA/Aronberg-000227- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000231 | |||||
| J14 | P09; | ||||
| D01, Ex. A | |||||
| D02, Ex. A-8 | |||||
| D03, Ex. A | 06/08/20 | Email to S. Mendelsohn from D. Wyler serving § 57.105 Demand Letter and Aronberg’s Motion for Attorneys’ Fees | CA/Aronberg-000232- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000236 | |||||
| J15 | P10; | ||||
| D02, Ex. A-7 | 06/08/20 | Order Granting Defendants Motions to Dismiss Count II of Plaintiff’s First Amended Complaint with Prejudice | CA/Aronberg-000273- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000243 | |||||
| J16 | P11; | ||||
| D01, Ex. B | |||||
| D02, Ex. A-9 | 06/23/20 | Letter to D. Wyler from S. Mendelsohn re: § 57.105 Demand Letter and Aronberg’s Motion for Attorneys’ Fees | CA/Aronberg-000244- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000246 | |||||
| J17 | P12; | ||||
| D01, Ex. C | |||||
| D02, Ex. A-10 | 07/01/20 | Defendant Dave Aronberg’s Motion for Attorneys’ Fees | CA/Aronberg-000247- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-00248 | |||||
| J18 | P13; | ||||
| D02, Ex. A-12 | 07/30/20 | Affidavit of David Aronberg | CA/Aronberg-000250- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000250 | |||||
| J19 | P14; | ||||
| D02, Ex. A-11 | 08/18/20 | Defendant Dave Aronberg’s Motion for Summary Final Judgment and Memorandum of Law in Support Thereof | CA/Aronberg-000251- | ||
| CA/Aronberg-000259 | |||||
| J20 | P15 | 10/02/20 | Memorandum of Law of Plaintiff CA Holdings, LLC in Opposition to The State Attorney’s Fla. Stat. Section 57.105 Motion | CA/Aronberg-000260- | |
| CA/Aronberg-000273 |
| TRIAL JOINT | PARTIES’ | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| EX. NO. EL NO. | EX. REFS. | DATE DESCRIPTION | NOS. |
| J21 | P16 | 10/14/20 Defendant, Dave Aronberg’s Response to Plaintiff’s Memorandum of Law in Opposition to The State Attorney’s Fla. Stat. Section 57.105 Motion | CA/Aronbere CA/Aronberg-000298 |
| J22 | P17 | 10/15/20 Letter to D. Wyler from S. Mendelsohn re: Settlement | CA/Aronberg-000299- CA/Aronberg-000300 |
| J23 | P18; DOI, Ex. D D02, Ex. A-I3 D03, Ex. B | 10 21/20 Plaintiff CA Holdings, LLC’s Notice of Dropping State Attorney, Dave Aronberg | CA/Aronberg-000301- CA/ ronberg-000302 |
| J24 | DOI, Ex. E | 11/06/20 Scholz & Wyler Invoice #00307 (S32,440.00) | A/Aronberg-000303- Aronberg-000309 |
| J25 | D01; D02, Ex. A-14 D03, Ex. C | 11/09/20 Defendant Dave Aronberg’s Amended , • Attorneys’ Fees | CA/Aronberg-000310- CA/Aronberg-000368 |
| J26 | D0I, Ex. F | 11/09/20 Affidavit of Attorneys’ Fees | CA/Aronberg-000369- CA/Aronberg-000388 CA/Aronberg-000389- |
| J27 | P20 | 04/22/21 Appendix to Motion of ’ Florida | |
| Holdings, LLC for S gment and | CA/Aronberg-001097 | ||
| Incorporated M Law | |||
| .112H | 1’19 | 04/22/21 Motion of PI ’ • Florida Holdings, LLC for | CA/Aronberg-001098- |
| Summary Incorporated Memorandum of Law | CA/Aronberg-001132 | ||
| .129 | 002 | 08/12/21 Am Me randum of Law in Support of | CA/Aronberg-001133- |
| e ye Aronberg’s Amended Motion for | CA/Aronberg-001470 | ||
| e Fees | |||
| .130 | 1’21 | 12/2 udgment | CA/Aronberg-001471- CA/Aronberg-001484 |
| .131 | P22 | 02/24 Amended Response and Memorandum of Law of | CA/Aronberg-001485- |
| t, | t , Plaintiff CA Holdings, LLC in Opposition to State Attorney Dave Aronberg’s Amended Motion for Attorneys’ Fees Under Florida Statutes Section $‘ | CA/Aronberg-001503 CA/Aronbera | |
| .132 | I Ex. (Ct | 04/12/22 Scholz & Wyler Invoice #00409 (S70,900.27) | CA/Aronberg-001512 CA/Aronberg-001513- |
| J | 003 | 04/13/22 Amended & Supplemental Affidavit of Attorneys’ Fees & Costs | CA/Aronberg-001594 |
| .134 | 04/13/22 Defendant, Dave Aronberg’s Notice of Dropping Cliam [sic) for Attorney Fee Multiplier | CAJAronberg-00I 595- CA/Aronberg-001596 | |
| .135 | 1)01 | 04/14/22 Amended and Supplemental Affidavit of Reasonable Attorneys’ Fees & Costs | CA/Aronberg-001597- CA/Aronberg-001600 |
| J36 | James v. Wile, 480 So. 2d 253 (Fla. 4th DCA 1985) CA/Aronberg-001600- | CA/Aronberg-001603 | |
| J37 | 10/09/19 Letter from M. Grygiel to D. Aronberg re: Public Records Law Requests | CA/Aronberg-001604- CA/Aronberg-001606 |
The Parties request that the Joint Exhibit List be admitted into evidence at the start of the evidentiary hearing without authentication or an offering witness.¶
Respectfully submitted,¶
/s/ Lauren Whetstone¶
LAUREN WHETSTONE¶
Florida Bar No. 45192¶
MARK F. BIDEAU¶
Florida Bar No. 564044¶
777 South Flagler Drive, Suite 300 East¶
West Palm Beach, FL 33401¶
Tel.: 561.650.7900¶
whetstonellagtlaw.com¶
thomasdO,gtlaw.com¶
FLService®gtlaw.com¶
STEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN¶
Florida Bar No. 849324¶
401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 2000¶
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301¶
Tel.: 954.768.8225¶
mendelsohns®gtlaw.com¶
smithlasrtlaw.com¶
MICHAEL J. GRYGIEL¶
(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)¶
GREENBERG TRAU P.¶
54 State Street, 6t oor¶
Albany, NY 1¶
Tel.: 518.68¶
‘el¶
NINA D. IAN¶
(Admitted o Hac Vice)¶
1840 Century Park East, Suite 1900¶
Los Angeles, CA 90067¶
Tel.: 310.586.7700¶
bovaiiannQatlaw.com¶
riveraal®gtlaw.com¶
Counsel for Plaintiff CA Florida Holdings, LLC,¶
Publisher of The Palm Beach Post¶
Is/ Douelas¶
ARTHUR I.¶
Florida Bar No. 10249¶
RICHARD J. SCHOLZ¶
Florida Bar No. 0021261¶
DOUGLAS A. WYLER¶
Florida Bar No. 11997¶
SCHOLZ &¶
961687 Gateway 201-I¶
Fernandina BeaclkFL 2034¶
Tel.: 904.2. .9¶
efendant Dave Aronberg, as ey for Palm Beach County.¶
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE¶
I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and accurate copy of the foregoing has been electronically filed with the Florida E-File Portal for e-service on all parties of record herein on this 1st day of September, 2022.¶
Is/ Lauren Whetstone¶
Lauren Whetstone O¶