IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, FOURTH DISTRICT¶
DCA NO.4D2024-0681¶
L.T. NO.50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB¶
CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC, Publisher of THE PALM BEACH POST Appellant(s),¶
VS.¶
DAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of Palm Beach County, Florida and SHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm Beach County, Florida Appellee(s).¶
RECORD ON APPEAL¶
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15{sup}TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL (CIRCUIT CIVIL DIVISION)¶
NINA D. BOYAUIAN boyajiann@gtlaw.com riveraal@gtlaw.com¶
MICHAEL J. GRYGIEL grygielm@gtlaw.com¶
COLLIN DOERN [REDACTED] cdjackson@mypalmbeachclerk.com¶
JESSICA NEER MCDONALD jessica@neermcd.com¶
STEPHEN ARTHUR MENDELSOHN mendelsohns@gtlaw.com hasenh@gtlaw.com FLService@gtlaw.com¶
DOUGLAS ARTHUR WYLER doug@jswflorida.com¶
NOT A CERTIFIED COPY¶
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH¶
| Date | Instrument | Pages |
|---|---|---|
| 04/17/24 | PROGRESS DOCKET | 0008-0013 |
| 11/14/19 | CIVIL COVER SHEET | 0014-0015 |
| 11/14/19 | COMPLAINT: F/B PLT | 0016-0105 |
| 11/15/19 | VERIFIED MOTION: FOR ADMISSION OF MICHAEL G | 0106-0111 |
| 11/19/19 | ORDER: HAFELE DTD 11/19/19: MOTION TO APP | |
| 12/06/19 | MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT DAVE ARONBERG AS | 0114-0116 |
| 12/13/19 | MOTION TO DISMISS: F/B DFT SHARON R BOCK AS | 0117-0120 |
| 01/16/20 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: KMARZ DTD 1/16/20 O | 0121-0122 |
| 01/16/20 | VERIFIED MOTION: AS TO PRO HAG VICE OF NINA | 0123-0127 |
| 01/17/20 | COMPLAINT: FIRST AMENDED F/B PLT | 0128-0221 |
| 01/17/20 | NOTICE OF FILING: FIRST [REDACTED] DED COMPLAINT F | 0222-0317 |
| 01/21/20 | ORDER: KMARX DTD 1/21/20 CANCELLING HEARIN | 0318-0319 |
| 01/21/20 | OBJECTION: PLAINTIFF’S OBJECTION TO DEFENDA | |
| 01/22/20 | ORDER GRANTING: DHAFELE DTD 1/22/20 MOTION | 0323-0324 |
| 01/24/20 | ANSWER: TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI | 0325-0337 |
| 01/24/20 | ANSWER: TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTI | 0338-0351 |
| 02/03/20 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: MARTZ DTD 2/3/20: 3 | 0352-0353 |
| 03/12/20 | NOTICE: OPPOSITION TO DFT DAVE ARONBEG STAT | |
| 03/12/20 | NOTICE: OPPOSITION TO DFT SHARON R. BOCK CL | |
| 03/18/20 | MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL: PLAINTIFF’S U | 0393-0395 |
| 03/20/20 | ORDER OF CONTINUANCE: MARX DTD 03/19 | 0396-0397 |
| 04/21/20 | ORDER RESETTING: ON MOTION TO DISMISS COUNT | |
| 05/22/20 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: MARX DTD 05/22/20 | 0400-0403 |
| 05/27/20 | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANGE OF ATTY | 0404-0404 |
| 06/08/20 | ORDER GRANTING: MARX; DFTS MOTIONS TO D | 0405-0411 |
| 06/10/20 | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: AND DIRECTIONS | 0412-0412 |
| 07/01/20 | MOTION: DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG’S MOTION F | 0413-0414 |
| 08/18/20 | MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: DEFENDANT DAVE | 0415-0423 |
| 08/18/20 | AFFIDAVIT: AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID ARONBERG | 0424-0425 |
| 09/18/20 | MOTION: MOTION TO SET CASE MANAGEMENT CONFE | 0426-0459 |
| 10/02/20 | MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN OPPOSITION TO THE STA | 0460-0473 |
| 10/14/20 | RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFF’S MEMORANDUM OF LAW | 0474-0498 |
| 10/21/20 | ORDER: HAFELE DTD 10/21/20: CASE MANAGEMEN | 0499-0499 |
| 10/21/20 | MOTION: MOTION TO SET HEARING ON DEFENDANT, | 0500-0501 |
| 10/21/20 | NOTICE OF DROPPING PARTY: AS TO DFT DAVE AR | 0502-0503 |
| 10/29/20 | MOTION: PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO DIRECT THE CL | 0504-0507 |
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH¶
| 11/09/20 | MOTION: DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG’S AMENDED M | 0508-0566 |
|---|---|---|
| 11/09/20 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AFFIDAVIT OF AT | 0567-0586 |
| 11/19/20 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: VERIFIED AFFIDA | 0587-0590 |
| 01/28/21 | NOTICE: OF CHANGE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD AND | 0591-0592 |
| 01/28/21 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE DTD 01/28/202 | 0593-0595 |
| 03/25/21 | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE: CHANGE OF COUN | 0596-0596 |
| 04/22/21 | MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT: AND INCORPORAT | 0597-0631 |
| 04/22/21 | APPENDIX: TO MOTION PLTS’ MOTION FOR SUMMAR | 0632-1341 |
| 05/24/21 | MOTION: PLAINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC | 1342-1345 |
| 05/25/21 | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AS COUNSEL FOR | 1346-1348 |
| 05/25/21 | RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO SCHEDULE | 1349-1352 |
| 06/11/21 | AGREED ORDER: HAFELE; ON PLTF’S MOTION TO S | [REDACTED] |
| 07/15/21 | MEMORANDUM OF LAW: AND RESPONSE IN OPPOSITI | 1355-1367 |
| 07/23/21 | AFFIDAVIT: OF DAVID ARONBERG FIL | 1368-1369 |
| 07/23/21 | TRANSCRIPT: OF HEARING ON 6-3-20 | 1370-1391 |
| 07/23/21 | MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN SUPPORT OF DAVE ARONB | 1392-1413 |
| 07/26/21 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: D HAFELE DTD. 7/26 | 1414-1417 |
| 07/26/21 | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: F/B ATTY WHETST | 1418-1420 |
| 07/26/21 | ORDER RESETTING: DHAFELE DTD 7/26/21 HEARI | 1421-1424 |
| 07/29/21 | MEMORANDUM OF LAW: IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT D | 1425-1571 |
| 08/05/21 | MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL: JOINT MOTION | 1572-1574 |
| 08/09/21 | ORDER: HAFELE DTD 8/5/21: JOINT MOTION TO | 1575-1577 |
| 08/12/21 | MEMORANDUM OF LAW: AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LA | 1578-1915 |
| 10/01/21 | RESPONSE TO:: PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR SUMMAR | 1916-1942 |
| 10/05/21 | ORDER: HAFELE: CONFIRMING HEARING ON PLAINT | 1943-1946 |
| 10/13/21 | REPLY/RESPONSE: IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF MOYIO | 1947-1957 |
| 12/20/21 | FINAL JUDGMENT: D HAFELE DTD 12/20/2021 | 1958-1971 |
| 01/03/22 | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: AND DESIGNATION | [REDACTED] |
| 01/03/22 | MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR | 1975-1979 |
| 01/19/22 | MOTION: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR | 1980-1987 |
| 01/26/22 | NOTICE: CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTR | 1988-1989 |
| 01/27/22 | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 1 | 1990-2010 |
| 02/24/22 | REPLY/RESPONSE: [AMENDED] AND MEMORANDUM OF | 2011-2029 |
| 03/30/22 | MOTION TO WITHDRAW: F/B DFT [REDACTED] | [REDACTED] |
| 03/30/22 | EXHIBIT: F/B DFT [REDACTED] ABRUZZO | 2033-2034 |
| 04/13/22 | NOTICE: DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG’S NOTICE O | 2035-2036 |
| 04/13/22 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED & SUPPL | 2037-2118 |
Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024¶
Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB¶
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC¶
| 04/14/22 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES: AMENDED AND SUP | 2119-2122 |
|---|---|---|
| 05/25/22 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: D. HAFELE DTD 05/25/ | 2123-2126 |
| 06/07/22 | ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL: HAFELE; COLIN D J | 2127-2129 |
| 07/01/22 | ORDER SETTING HEARING: HAFELE: (RESETTING) | 2130-2132 |
| 07/22/22 | MOTION: AGREED MOTION OF PLAINTIFF CA FLORI | 2133-2152 |
| 09/08/22 | CLERK’S NOTE: EVIDENTIARY HEARING 9/07/22 | 2153-2155 |
| 09/26/22 | MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME: TO SUBMIT WRI | [REDACTED] |
| 09/28/22 | AGREED ORDER: DELGADO: ON JOINT MOTION FOR | 2159-2159 |
| 10/04/22 | EXHIBIT LIST | 2160-2161 |
| 10/04/22 | TRANSCRIPT: HEARING PROCEEDINGS DTD SEPTE | 2162-2440 |
| 10/06/22 | NOTICE: CLOSING ARGUMENT OF DEFENDANT, DAVE | 2441-2469 |
| 10/06/22 | NOTICE: WRITTEN CLOSING ARGUMENT OF CA FLOR | 2470-2574 |
| 02/01/23 | ORDER DENYING: L DELGADO DTD. 1/31/23 | 2575-2576 |
| 02/01/23 | MOTION: TO ALTER OR AMEND ORDER DENYING THE | 2577-2578 |
| 02/16/23 | RESPONSE TO:: IN OPPOSITION TO STATE ATTY D | 2579-2585 |
| 03/01/23 | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 1 | 2586-2589 |
| 03/06/23 | ORDER: DELGADO DTD 3/6/23: MOTION TO ALTER | 2590-2591 |
| 03/10/23 | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 3 | 2592-2595 |
| 05/11/23 | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL: F/B ATTY JACK S | 2596-2597 |
| 06/09/23 | ORDER: DELGADO; DIRECTING CLERK TO COURT TO | 2598-2600 |
| 06/29/23 | ORDER: DELGADO DTD 6/29/23: DIRECTING TRA | 2601-2604 |
| 02/23/24 | MOTION: THE ASSOCIATED PRESS’ MOTION FOR LI | 2605-2608 |
| 02/28/24 | AGREED ORDER: L DELGADO DTD. 2/28/24 GRANT | 2609-2609 |
| 02/29/24 | ORDER: L. DELGADO DTD 2/29/2024 ON GRAND JU | 2610-2614 |
| 03/01/24 | MOTION: THE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC’S MOTION | 2615-2617 |
| 03/04/24 | NOTICE: THE MCCLATCHY COMPANY, LLC’S NOTICE | 2618-2619 |
| 03/05/24 | AGREED ORDER: DELGADO DTD 3/5/24: MOTION | 2620-2620 |
| 03/14/24 | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL: ORDER RENDERED ON 2 | 2621-2629 |
| 04/17/24 | CERTIFICATE | 4262-4262 |
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH¶
| Party | Description | Pages |
|---|---|---|
| JOINT | J18 AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID ARONBERG | 2630-2631 |
| JOINT | J16 LETTER TO D. WYLER FROM S MENDELSOHN | |
| JOINT | J24 [REDACTED] SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE | 2635-2641 |
| JOINT | J20 MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF PLAINTIFF CA HOLDI | 2642-2655 |
| JOINT | J21 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG’S RESPONSE TO | 2656-2680 |
| JOINT | J13 HEARING TRANSCRIPT | 2681-2685 |
| JOINT | J19 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG’S MOTION FOR SU | 2686-2694 |
| JOINT | J17 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG’S MOTION FOR AT | 2695-2696 |
| JOINT | J10 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG AS STATE ATTOR | 2697-2709 |
| JOINT | J23 PLAINTIFF CA HOLDINGS, LLC’S NOTICE OF | 2710-2711 |
| JOINT | J15 ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DIS | |
| JOINT | J11 DEFENDANT ARONBERG TWITTER POST | 2719-2720 |
| JOINT | J12 SAO15 PRESS RELEASE | 2721-2721 |
| JOINT | J22 LETTER TO D. WYLER FROM S MENDELSOHN | 2722-2723 |
| JOINT | J14 EMAIL TO S. MENDELSOHN FROM D WYLER | 2724-2728 |
| JOINT | J05 LETTER TO J. HOWARD FROM D. WYLER | 2729-2729 |
| JOINT | J04 SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT | 2730-2821 |
| JOINT | J08 ORDER DENYING THE STATE’S MOTION FOR AN | 2822-2828 |
| JOINT | J06 MOTION TO DISMISS | 2829-2831 |
| JOINT | J03 LETTER TO MUSGRAVE FROM N. CRUZ | |
| JOINT | J02 LETTER TO J. PACENTI FROM N. CRUZ | 2835-2835 |
| JOINT | J07 MOTION FOR AN ORDER UNSEALING GRAND JUR | 2836-2841 |
| JOINT | J01 LETTER TO D. ARONBERG FROM S. MENDELSOH | 2842-2844 |
| JOINT | J09 FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART II) | 2845-2938 |
| JOINT | J09 FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT (PART I) | 2939-2964 |
| JOINT | J30 FINAL JUDGMENT | 2965-2978 |
| JOINT | J32 [REDACTED] SCHOLZ & WYLER INVOICE | 2979-2987 |
| JOINT | J26 AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY’S FEES | 2988-3007 |
| JOINT | J31 AMENDED RESPONSE AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW | 3008-3026 |
| JOINT | J28 MOTION OF PLAINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDING | 3027-3061 |
| JOINT | J25 DEFENDANT DAVE ARONBERG’S AMENDED MOTIO | 3062-3120 |
| JOINT | J37 LETTER FROM M GRYGIEL TO D. ARONBERG | 3121-3123 |
| JOINT | J34 DEFENDANT, DAVE ARONBERG’S NOTICE OF DR | 3124-3125 |
| JOINT | J36 JAMES V WILLE, 480 SO.2D. 253 (1985) | 3126-3128 |
| JOINT | J33 AMENDED & SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF AT | 3129-3210 |
| JOINT | J35 AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF | 3211-3214 |
Record on Appeal Index Wednesday, April 17, 2024¶
Case #: 502019CA014681XXXXMB¶
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEAC¶
| JOINT | J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT O | 3215-3374 |
|---|---|---|
| JOINT | J29 AMENDED MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT O | 3375-3552 |
| JOINT | J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA H | 3553-3725 |
| JOINT | J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO | 3726-3900 |
| JOINT | J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO | 3901-4086 |
| JOINT | J27 APPENDIX TO MOTION OF PLT CA FLORIDA HO | 4087-4261 |
NOTA CERTIFIED¶
| ---- | ---------------- | ------- | ----------------------------------- | | 1 | 11/14/2019 | | CIVIL COVER SHEET | | 2 | 11/14/2019 | | SUMMONS ISSUED | | 3 | 11/14/2019 | | SUMMONS ISSUED | | 4 | 11/14/2019 | | COMPLAINT | | 5 | 11/15/2019 | | DIVISION ASSIGNMENT | | 6 | 11/15/2019 | | PAID ON RECEIPT | | 7 | 11/15/2019 | | VERIFIED MOTION | | 8 | 11/15/2019 | | PAID ON RECEIPT | | 9 | 11/19/2019 | | ORDER | | 10 | 11/25/2019 | | SERVICE RETURNED (NUMBERED) | | 11 | 11/25/2019 | | SERVICE RETURNED (NUMBERED) | | 12 | 12/6/2019 | | MOTION TO DISMISS | | 13 | 12/13/2019 | | MOTION TO DISMISS | | 14 | 1/16/2020 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 15 | 1/16/2020 | | VERIFIED MOTION | | 16 | 1/17/2020 | | PAID ON RECEIPT | | 17 | 1/17/2020 | | COMPLAINT | | 18 | 1/17/2020 | | NOTICE OF FILING | | 19 | 1/21/2020 | | ORDER | | 21 | 1/21/2020 | | OBJECTION | | 20 | 1/22/2020 | | ORDER GRANTING | | 22 | 1/24/2020 | | ANSWER | | 23 | 1/24/2020 | | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY | | 24 | 1/24/2020 | | ANSWER | | 25 | 2/3/2020 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 26 | 3/12/2020 | | NOTICE | | 27 | 3/12/2020 | | NOTICE | | 28 | 3/18/2020 | | MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE CIVIL | | 29 | 3/20/2020 | | ORDER OF CONTINUANCE | | 30 | 4/21/2020 | | ORDER RESETTING | | 31 | 5/22/2020 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 32 | 5/27/2020 | | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE | | 33 | 6/8/2020 | | ORDER GRANTING | | 34 | 6/10/2020 | | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE | | 35 | 7/1/2020 | | MOTION |¶
| ---- | ---------------- | ------- | ----------------------------- | | 36 | 7/10/2020 | | REQUEST TO PRODUCE | | 37 | 7/24/2020 | | REQUEST TO PRODUCE | | 38 | 8/18/2020 | | MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT | | 39 | 8/18/2020 | | AFFIDAVIT | | 40 | 9/2/2020 | | RESPONSE TO REQ TO PRODUCE | | 41 | 9/18/2020 | | MOTION | | 42 | 9/22/2020 | | NOTICE OF HEARING | | 43 | 10/2/2020 | | MEMORANDUM OF LAW | | 44 | 10/2/2020 | | RESPONSE TO: | | 45 | 10/14/2020 | | RESPONSE TO: | | 46 | 10/21/2020 | | ORDER | | 47 | 10/21/2020 | | MOTION | | 48 | 10/21/2020 | | NOTICE OF DROPPING PARTY | | 49 | 10/29/2020 | | MOTION | | 50 | 11/9/2020 | | MOTION | | 51 | 11/9/2020 | | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES | | 52 | 11/19/2020 | | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES | | 53 | 12/3/2020 | | NOTICE OF NON JURY TRIAL | | 54 | 12/10/2020 | | NOTICE OF NON JURY TRIAL | | 55 | 1/28/2021 | | NOTICE | | 56 | 1/28/2021 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 57 | 3/25/2021 | | NOTICE -NAME/ADDRESS CHANGE | | 58 | 4/22/2021 | | MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT | | 59 | 4/22/2021 | | APPENDIX | | 60 | 5/24/2021 | | MOTION | | 61 | 5/25/2021 | | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL | | 62 | 5/25/2021 | | RESPONSE TO: | | 63 | 6/11/2021 | | AGREED ORDER | | 64 | 7/15/2021 | | MEMORANDUM OF LAW | | 66 | 7/23/2021 | | AFFIDAVIT | | 67 | 7/23/2021 | | TRANSCRIPT | | 68 | 7/23/2021 | | MEMORANDUM OF LAW | | 65 | 7/26/2021 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 69 | 7/26/2021 | | NOTICE OF APPEARANCE CIVIL | | 70 | 7/26/2021 | | ORDER RESETTING |¶
| 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 89 83 84 85 86 87 88 90 91 92 93 94 | Effective Date 7/29/2021 8/5/2021 8/9/2021 8/12/2021 10/1/2021 10/5/2021 10/13/2021 12/20/2021 12/20/2021 1/3/2022 1/3/2022 1/19/2022 1/26/2022 1/27/2022 1/27/2022 1/27/2022, 1/27/2022 1/27/2022 1/28/2022 2/24/2022 3/22/2022 3/22/20 3/23 3/ 0 | Count Description MEMORANDUM OF LAW ORDER I MEMORANDUM OF LAW RESPONSE TO: ORDER REPLY/RESPONSE FINAL JUDGMENT DISPOSED AFTER OTHER NOTICE OF APPEARV CIVIL MOTION 4CI’ MOTION NOTICE NOTICE O AL CIVIL PAID ON RECEIPT AUTOMATI RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING TRUE COPY TR E COPY PLY/RESPONSE ,INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL INVOICE 2 |
|---|---|---|
| 95 | 2 | MOTION TO WITHDRAW |
| 96 | 3 /2022 | EXHIBIT |
| 99 | 4/13/2022 | NOTICE |
| 100 | 4/13/2022 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES |
| 97 | 4/14/2022 | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY |
| 98 | 4/14/2022 | AFFIDAVIT OF ATTORNEY FEES |
| 101 | 4/20/2022 | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY |
| 102 | 4/28/2022 | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY |
| 103 | 5/25/2022 | ORDER SETTING HEARING |
| 1011._ , | 5/31/2022 | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY |
| 105 | 6/2/2022 | NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY |
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE¶
| ----- | ---------------- | ------- | ------------------------------------ | | 106 | 6/7/2022 | | ORD SUBSTITUTION COUNSEL | | 107 | 7/1/2022 | | ORDER SETTING HEARING | | 108 | 7/22/2022 | | MOTION | | 109 | 9/1/2022 | | EVIDENCE/EXHIBIT LIST FILED | | 110 | 9/8/2022 | | CLERK’S NOTE | | 111 | 9/26/2022 | | MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME | | 112 | 9/28/2022 | | AGREED ORDER | | 113 | 10/4/2022 | | EXHIBIT LIST | | 114 | 10/4/2022 | | TRANSCRIPT | | 115 | 10/6/2022 | | NOTICE | | 116 | 10/6/2022 | | NOTICE | | 117 | 2/1/2023 | | ORDER DENYING | | 118 | 2/1/2023 | | MOTION | | 119 | 2/16/2023 | | RESPONSE TO: | | 120 | 3/1/2023 | | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL | | 121 | 3/1/2023 | | PAID ON RECEIPT | | 122 | 3/1/2023 | | AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING | | 123 | 3/3/2023 | | ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE | | 124 | 3/6/2023 | | TRUE COPY | | 125 | 3/6/2023 | | ORDER | | 126 | 3/10/2023 | | NOTICE OF APPEAL CIVIL | | 127 | 3/10/2023 | | PAID ON RECEIPT | | 128 | 3/20/2023 | | TRUE COPY | | 129 | 3/27/2023 | | EXHIBIT CHECK OUT RECEIPT | | 130 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 131 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 132 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 133 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 134 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 135 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 136 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 137 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 138 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 139 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE | | 140 | 3/27/2023 | | JOINT EVIDENCE |¶
| # 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 | Effective Date 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/2023 3/27/20 3/27 • 3 3/ 0 | Count Description JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDEN JOINT EVIDEt JOINT EV JOINT E JOI VID NCE J ENCE T VIDENCE JO EVIDENCE J INT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE ’ JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE JOINT EVIDENCE |
|---|---|---|
| 165 | 13 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 166 | 3 /2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 167 | 3/28/2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 168 | 3/28/2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 169 | 3/28/2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 170 | 3/28/2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 171 | 3/28/2023 | JOINT EVIDENCE |
| 172 | 4/5/2023 | INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL |
| 173. | 4/5/2023 | INVOICE |
| 174 | 4/14/2023 | __PAID ON RECEIPT |
| 175 | 4/17/2023 | AUTOMATIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING |
Case Description: CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH POST V ARONBERG, DAVE¶
| Effective | Date Count Description |
|---|---|
| 178 | 5/11/2023 |
| 179 | 5/26/2023 |
| 188 | 5/26/2023 |
| 180 | 6/9/2023 |
| 181 | 6/29/2023 |
| 182 | 2/23/2024 |
| 183 | 2/28/2024 |
| 184 | 2/29/2024 |
| 185 | 3/1/2024 |
| 186 | 3/4/2024 |
| 187 | 3/5/2024 |
| 189 | 3/14/2024 |
| 190 | 3/14/2024 |
| 191 | 3/14/2024 |
| 192 | 3/15/2024 |
| 193 | 3/15/2024 |
| 194 | 3/15/2024 |
| 195 | 4/3/2024 |
| 196 | 4/4/2024 |
| NOTICE O 13,EAL CIVIL | |
| PAID ON RECEIPT | |
| AUTO TIC RECEIPT APPELLATE FILING | |
| ACKNlaWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE |
MANDATE-AFFIRMED¶
ABRUZZO LA.r.tru• ur r. LIKUL IT COURT & COMPTROLLER PALM BEACH COUNTY F. (561) 355.2500 F (561) 355.6211¶
County CIMI Division PO Box 3406 West Palm Beach. FL 33402¶
CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK¶
4th DCA NO.: 4D2024-0681¶
ABRUZZO, Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comp r, in and for Palm Beach County, State of Florida, do hereby certi at e foregoing pages of:¶
CA FLORIDA HOLDINGS LLC PUBLISHER OF THECQEACH POST¶
vs¶
DAVE ARONBEg4ic)¶
CASE NO: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX¶
contains true and correct transcripts pies of all such papers and proceedings in said cause as app k fr the records and files of my office that have been directed t inbtuded in said RECORD by the directions furnished to me, vytth Clactions required by law, rule or administrative order.¶
IN WITNESS WH F, I have hereunto my hand affixed the seal of the court, this 1Tolf,April, 2024¶
By: Brent Robbins Deputy Clerk¶
ABRUZZO CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT & COMPTROLLER Palm Beach County, FL.¶