## Exhibit 4 (File Under Seal)

## United States District Court For The Southern District of New York

v. Maxwell 15-cs-07433-RWS

Ghislaine Maxwell's Privilege Log Amended as of August 1, 2016

\*\*\*Per Local Rule 26.2. the following privileges are asserted pursuant to British law, Colorado law and NY law.

| Log ID | DATE         | DOC.    |        |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
| ------ | ------------ | ------- | ------ | ------------------- | -------------------- | ----- | ----------------- | ---------------- |
|        |              |         |        | FROM                | ill TO               | CC    | RELATIONSHIP      |                  |
| I.     | 2011.03.15   | E-Mails | 10(X)- |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Brett Jaffe, Esq.    |       | Attorney / Client | Communication    |
|        |              |         |        |                     |                      |       |                   | re: legal advice |
| 2.     | 2011.03.15   | E-Mails | 1014-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Brett Salle. Esq.   | Ghislaine Maxwell    |       | Attorney / Client | Communication    |
| 3.     | 2015.01.02   | E-Mails | 1020-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Gow                 | Ghislaine Maxwell    |       | Attorney Agent /  |                  |
| 4.     | 2015.01.02   | E-Mail  | 1024-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Gow                  |       | Attorney Agent /  |                  |
| 5.     | 2015.01.02   | E-Mail  | 1027-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Gow                 | Ghislaine Maxwell    | Brian |                   |                  |
| 6.     | 2015.01.06   | E-Mail  | 1029   | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Jeffrey Epstein      |       | Common Interest   | Communication    |
| 7.     | 2015.01.06   | E-Mail  | 1030-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Jeffrey Epstein,     |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        |                     |                      |       | Attorney / Client | Communication    |
| 8.     | 2015.01.10   | E-Mail  | 1044   | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Phili, Barden, Esq., |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        |                     |                      |       | Attorney / Client | Communication    |
| 9.     | 2015.01.10   | E-Mail  | 1045-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Philip Barden. Esq.  |       | Client / Attorney | Communication    |
| 10.    | 2015.01.09 - |         |        |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              | E-Mails | 1052-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Gow                 | Philip Barden, Esq.  | G.    |                   |                  |
| 11.    | 2015.01.11   | E-Mail  | 1055-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Jeffrey Epstein      |       | Common Interest   | Communication    |
| 12.    | 2015.01.11   | E-Mail  | 1055-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Philip Barden. Esq. | Gow                  | G.    |                   |                  |
| 13.    | 2015.01.11   | E-Mail  | 1056-  |                     |                      |       |                   |                  |
|        |              |         |        | Philip Barden, Esq. | Ghislaine Maxwell    |       |                   |                  |

| 14. | 2015.01.11 -  |         |         |                     |                                |                        |                       |
| --- | ------------- | ------- | ------- | ------------------- | ------------------------------ | ---------------------- | --------------------- |
|     |               | E-Mails | 1059-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Jeffrey Epstein     | Ghislaine Maxwell              | Common Interest        | Communication         |
| 15. | 2015.01.13    | E-Mail  | 1067-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Jeffrey Epstein                | Common Interest        | Communication         |
| 16. | 2015.01.13    | E-Mail  | 1069-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Philip Barden. Esq. | Weinberg. Esq.                 | Common Interest        | Communication         |
| 17. | 2015.01.13    | E-Mails | 1068-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Philip Barden. Esq. | Ghislaine Maxwell              | Mark Attorney / Client | Communication         |
| 18. | 2015.01.21    | E-Mail  | 1088-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Gow                 | Philip Barden. Esq., Ghislaine |                        |                       |
| 19. | 2015.01.21 -  |         |         |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               | E-Mails | 1084-   |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         | Jeffrey Epstein     | Ghislaine Maxwell              | Common Interest        | Communication         |
| 20. | 2015.01.2 1 - |         |         |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               | E-Mails | 1099    | Ghislaine Maxwell   | Jeffrey Epstein                | Common Interest        | Communication         |
| 21. | 2015.04.22    | E-mail  | 7 pages | Jeffrey Epstein     | Ghislaine Maxwell              | Common Interest        | Forwarding            |
| 22. | Various       | E-mails |         | A ae f Haddon.      |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         |                     | of Haddon. &                   | Agent of attorney and  |                       |
|     |               |         |         |                     | iisu                           |                        | Attorney Work Product |
| 23. | Various       | E-mails |         | Mary Borja: Laura   |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         |                     | Mary Borja: Laura Menninger    | Attorney Work          |                       |
| 24. | 2015.10.21 -  |         |         |                     |                                |                        |                       |
|     |               |         |         |                     | Darren Indyke: Laura Menninger | Attorneys for parties  |                       |
| 25. | 2015.01.06    |         |         |                     |                                | Attorney/Client        | Document              |

| 26. | 2015.01.23 | Attorney/Client | Document    | Attorney Work Product: |
| --- | ---------- | --------------- | ----------- | ---------------------- |
|     |            |                 | prepared by | Attorney-Client        |
|     |            |                 | Ghislaine   | Communication          |