EFTA00168352 ADDENDUM Client: Federal Bureau of Investigation Property Address: 9 East 71st Street City: New York State: NY Zip: 10021 Property Rights Appraised: Fee Simple General Comments The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the market value of the subject property as of the effective date of the appraisal. The report will function as a guide for the client mentioned in this report. In preparing this appraisal, the appraiser has been requested to perform an exterior viewing only and not to disturb the occupants by entering the building. The physical characteristics used to develop this appraisal are based on the assessment records and on the multiple listing service if available. The subject was observed from the public street as of the effective date of the appraisal. Based on the observed conditions, the assessment records and multiple listing service information appear to be accurate. For the purposes of this appraisal, it is assumed that the interior condition of the subject property is consistent with the exterior conditions as observed, and that the information concerning the interior condition as provided by the assessor's records and the multiple listing service is accurate. Per prior agreement with the client, the appraiser did not value the site and did not use the cost approach to value, although this approach would generally be considered meaningful in appraising a property of this type. Data was collected from a variety of sources including, but not limited to, public land records, a multiple listing service, tax records, brokers, buyers, sellers, comps inc. And in-office files. The form summarizes the process and conclusion of the value for the sales comparison approach and a final value conclusion. Additional supporting data can be found in our appraisal file. The highest and best use is considered to be as is. The subject is not a manufactured home and is permanently affixed to the foundation. Manufactured homes are not common to this area. It should be noted that a review of all transfers of residential property known to have taken place in the subject area was undertaken before comparable sale selection was finalized. Due to the subject only being viewed from the street and the appraiser not being able to measure the subject, the gross living area information was obtained from the assessor's office (if possible) or was estimated by the appraiser. The tax information in this report has been given to the appraiser by the respective town and/or village and is assumed to be correct. This appraiser assumes a certificate of occupancy exists for the subject as described herein. The client ordered this appraisal as an exterior only report. No interior viewing was completed. The occupancy is marked on the first page based on the norm for the neighborhood, unless otherwise noted. The appraiser reserves the right to revise this report upon a full viewing of the subject property. For the purpose of this appraisal report, the word inspect should be view or viewed. This would mean that the appraiser has viewed, not inspected, the property and it's characteristics. The appraiser is not an expert in the field of engineering, home inspections or environmental issues. The appraiser views the property where possible and reports what is seen. No tests of any sort were prepared to draw any conclusions. This appraiser is not and engineer or home inspector, therefor the reader of this report should not rely on this appraisal as a substitute for a home inspection. The electronic signatures in this report are secured with security protected access codes. This has been approved and accepted by uspap, the appraisal institute as well as major banks and lending institutions including fannie mae. Note that the photographs submitted with this appraisal report are original digital images. These digital images have not been altered or modified in any shape or form as to mislead the reader of this report. If there were any people in the pictures, they have been removed. The map in this report is generated by the computer. The accuracy may not be to the exact location but is very close and is not intended to mislead the reader. This report was ordered as an exterior report only. Due to this fact, the appraiser does not know if the utilities are on or off , if repairs are needed, and what a cost to cure would be. Unless otherwise stated in this report, the existence of hazardous materials, which may or may not be present on the property, was not observed by the appraiser. The appraiser has no knowledge of the existence of such materials on or in the property. The appraiser, however, is not qualified to detect such substances. The presence of substances such as asbestos, urea-formaldehyde foam insulation, and other potentially hazardous materials may affect the value of the property. The value estimated is predicated on the assumption that there is no such material on or in the property that would cause a loss in value. No responsibility is assumed for such conditions or for any expertise or engineering knowledge required to discover them. The intended user is urged to retain an expert in this field if desired. The intended User of this appraisal report is an agency of the United States Government. The intended Use is to evaluate the property that is the subject of this appraisal for an estimated market value, subject to the stated Scope of Work, purpose of the appraisal, reporting requirements of this appraisal form, and Definition of Market Value. No additional Intended Users are identified by the appraiser. USAO 000378 Addendum Page 1 of 2 EFTA_00018288 EFTA00168353 ADDENDUM | Client: Federal Bureau of Investigation | File No.: F987005 1 | | :--- | :--- | | Property Address: 9 East 71st Street | Case No.: | | City: New York | State: NY | Zip: 10021 | USAO 000379 | EFTA_00018289 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown representation of the provided image, preserving the original layout with headings, paragraphs, and formulas as they appear. No additional content has been added or removed. EFTA00168354 APPRAISAL REPORTS, INC. Single Family Residential Property Market Listings File No. F907005.1
FEATURESUBJECTLISTING #1LISTING #2LISTING #3
9 East 71st Street Address New York, NY12 East 63rd Street134 Charles Street
New York, NY 10065New York, NY 10014
0.43 miles SW3.38 miles SW
Proximity to Subject
Original List Price$67,000,000$80,000,000
Current List Price$67,000,000$80,000,000
Last Price Revision Date1/1/201911/5/2018
Sale Price$
Price Gross Lot Area$ 0.00 sq. ft.15,153.84 sq. ft.15,125.57 sq. ft.$ sq. ft.
Data Source(s)StreetEasy.comStreetEasy.com
Verification Source(s)CoronranBespoke Real Estate LLC
VALUE ADJUSTMENTSDESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION<=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION<=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION<=1 Adjustment
Days on Market188251
Sale or Financing ConcessionsLISTING-6,700,000LISTING-8,000,000
LocationUrbanUrban
Leasehold Free SampleFee SimpleFee SimpleFee Simple
SiteWide/518 sq. ft.Level/2500510,800Wide/4745+36,300
ViewCityCityCity-100,000
Design (Style)1-Fam Attached1-Fam Attached1-Fam Attached
Quality of ConstructionLimestone/GoodLimes/Brick/GdBrick/Good
Actual Age109 +/- Years109 +/- Years109 +/- Years
ConditionVery GoodVery GoodVery Good
Above GradeBelow GradeBelow GradeBelow GradeBelow GradeTop ItemsBottom Items
New Count40 UUNK14.78.5+100,0001568.5
Gross Living Area18,814 sq. ft.13,00011,628 sq. ft.13,060$11,508,000$q.ft.
Basement & Filled Rooms Below GradeFull BasementFull BasementFull BasementFull BasementFull Basement
Functional Utility1-Fam/Good1-Fam/Good1-Fam/Good1-Fam/Good1-Fam/Good
Energy Efficient ItemsInsul WindowsInsul WindowsInsul WindowsInsul WindowsInsul Windows
Garage CarportPatioPoolNone
Porch/Patio DeckSquash Court-25,000
Net Adjustment (Total)X$\cdot$$5,538,800X$\cdot$$$\cdot$$
Adjusted Use PriceNet Adj. $ 8.3%Net Adj. $ 28.3%Net Adj. $ 72,538,000Net Adj. $ 4.3%Net Adj. $ 24.6%Net Adj. $ 83,419,300Net Adj. %Net Adj. %Net Adj. %
Comments on Market ListingsListings were adjusted for lack of premium wide frontage.
SFR_05_Listings: 07212014 Produced using ACI software, 003.234.8727 www.acciweb.com USAO 000380 | EFTA_00018290 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown representation of the provided image, preserving the original layout with headings, paragraphs, and formulas as they appear. No additional content has been added or removed. EFTA00168355 APPRAISAL REPORTS, INC. Single Family Residential Property Market Listings File No. F907005.1
FEATURESUBJECTLISTING # 4LISTING # 5LISTING # 6
9 East 71st Street
Address New York, NY
Proximity to Subject
Original List Price$
Current List Price$
Last Price Revision Date
Sale Price$
Price Gross Lot Area$ 0.00 sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.
Data Sources(s)
Verification Sources(s)
VALUE ADJUSTMENTSDESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION<=1.5 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION>=1.5 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION<=1.5 Adjustment
Days on Market
Sale or Financing Conclusions
LocationUrban
Leasehold Fee SimpleFee Simple
SiteWide/5108 sq. ft.
ViewCity
Design (Style)1-Fam Attached
Quality of ConstructionLimestone/Good
Actual Age109 +/- Years
ConditionVery Good
Above Grade Rooms Count40 U UNKTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBaths
Gross Living Area18,814 sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.
Basement Finished Rooms Below GradeFull Basement
Functional Utility1-Fam/Good
Interior ControlHW/Radiant/Cent
Energy Efficient ItemsInsul Windows
Garage CarportNone
Porch/Patio DeckPatio
Net Adjustment (Total)□ - □ - $□ - □ - $□ - □ - $
Adjusted List PriceNet Adj. %$Net Adj. %$Net Adj. %$
ITEMSUBJECTLISTING # 4LISTING # 5LISTING # 6
Date of Prior Sale/Transfer12/23/2011
Price of Prior Sale/Transfer$10
Data Sources(s)ACRIS
Effective Date of Data Sources(s)7/14/2019
Comments on Market Listings
SFR_05_Listings: 07212014 Produced using ACI software, 800 234 8727 www.acciweb.com USAO 000381 | EFTA_00018291 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown document with no headings, paragraphs, or tables. It contains just the text "EFTA_00018291". EFTA00168356 APPRAISAL REPORTS, INC. Single Family Residential Property Market Listings File No. F907005.1
FEATURESUBJECTLISTING # 7LISTING # 8LISTING # 9
9 East 71st Street
Address New York, NY
Proximity to Subject
Original List Price$
Current List Price$
Last Price Revision Date
Sale Price$
Price Gross Lot Area$ 0.00 sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.
Data Sources(s)
Verification Sources(s)
VALUE ADJUSTMENTSDESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION<=1.5 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION>=1.5 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION<=1.5 Adjustment
Days on Market
Sale or Financing Conclusions
LocationUrban
Leasehold Fee SimpleFee Simple
SiteWide/5108 sq. ft.
ViewCity
Design (Style)1-Fam Attached
Quality of ConstructionLimestone/Good
Actual Age109 +/- Years
ConditionVery Good
Above Grade Rooms Count40 U UNKTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBaths
Gross Living Area18,814 sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.
Basement Finished Rooms Below GradeFull Basement
Functional Utility1-Fam/Good
Interior ControlHW/Radiant/Cent
Energy Efficient ItemsInsul Windows
Garage CarportNone
Porch/Patio DeckPatio
Net Adjustment (Total)□ - □ - $□ - □ - $□ - □ - $
Adjusted List PriceNet Adj. %$Net Adj. %$Net Adj. %$
ITEMSUBJECTLISTING # 7LISTING # 8LISTING # 9
Date of Prior Sale/Transfer12/23/2011
Price of Prior Sale/Transfer$10
Data Sources(s)ACRIS
Effective Date of Data Sources(s)7/14/2019
Comments on Market Listings
SFR_05_Listings: 07212014 Produced using ACI software, 800 234 8727 www.acciweb.com USAO 000382 | EFTA_00018292 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown document with no headings, paragraphs, or tables. It contains just the text "EFTA_00018292". EFTA00168357 APPRAISAL REPORTS, INC. Single Family Residential Property Market Listings File No. F907005.1
FEATURESUBJECTLISTING # 10LISTING # 11LISTING # 12
9 East 71st Street Address New York, NY
Prominency to Subject
Original List Price$$
Current List Price$$
Last Price Revision Date$
Sale Price$
Price Range, Liv Area$ 0.00 sq. ft.$ sq. ft.
Data Source(s)
Verification Source(s)
VALUE ADJUSTMENTSDESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION<=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION>=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION<=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION>=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION
Days on Market
Sale or Financing Concessions
LocationUrban
Leasehold/Free Simple SiteFee Simple Wide/5108 sq. ft.
CityCity
Design (Style)1-Fam Attached
Quality of ConstructionLimestone/Good
Actual Age109 +/- Years
ConditionVery Good
Above Grade Rooms Count40 U UNKTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBathsTotal BedsBaths
Gross Living Area18,814 sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.
Basement & Finished Rooms Below GradeFull Basement
Functional Utility1-Fam/Good
Interior DesignHW/Restland/Cent
Energy Efficient ItemsInsul Windows
Garage CarportNone
Porch/Patio/DeckPatio
Net Adjustment (Total)□ - □:$□ - □:$□ - □:$□ - □:$
Adjusted List PriceNet Adj. % Gross Adj. %$$Net Adj. % Gross Adj. %$Net Adj. % Gross Adj. %$Net Adj. % Gross Adj. %$
ITEM SUBJECTLISTING # 10LISTING # 11LISTING # 12
Date of Prior Sale Transfer 12/23/2019
Price of Prior Sale Transfer $10
Data Source(s) ACRIS
Effective Date of Data Source(s) 7/14/2019
Comments on Market Listings
SFR_05_Listings: 07212014 Produced using ACI software, 800 234.8727 www.sciweb.com USAO 000383 | EFTA_00018293 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown document with no headings, paragraphs, or tables. It contains just one line of text. EFTA00168358 APPRAISAL REPORTS, INC. Single Family Residential Property Market Listings File No. F907005.1
FEATURESUBJECTLISTING # 13LISTING # 14LISTING # 15
9 East 71st Street
Address New York, NY
Proximity to Subject
Original List Price$
Current List Price$
Last Price Revision Date$
Sale Price$
Price/Gross Lif Area$ 0.00 sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.$ sq. ft.
Data Source(s)
Verification Source(s)
VALUE ADJUSTMENTSDESCRIPTIONDESCRIPTION<=1 AdjustmentDESCRIPTION>=1 Adjustment<=1 Adjustment
Days on Market
Sale or Financing Conclusions
LocationUrban
Leasehold Free Simple SiteFee Simple
Wide/5108 sq. ft.
CityCity
Design (Style)1-Fam Attached
Limestone/Good
Quality of Construction
Actual Age109 +/- Years
ConditionVery Good
Above Grade Rooms Below Grade40 U UNKTotal BedsBathsTotal StallsBathsTotal BedsBathsTotal StallsBaths
Gross Living Area18,814 sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.sq. ft.
Basement & Finished Rooms Below GradeFull Basement
Functional Utility1-Fam/Good
Interior DesignHW/Wardlent/Cent
Energy Efficient ItemsInsul Windows
Garage/CarportNone
Porch/Patio DeckPatio
Net Adjustment (Total)□- □- $□- □- $□- □- $
Adjusted List PriceNet Adj. % Gross Ad. %Net Adj. % Gross Ad. %Net Adj. % Gross Ad. %
ITEMSUBJECTLISTING # 13LISTING # 14LISTING # 15
Date of Prior Sale/Transfer12/23/2011
Price of Prior Sale/Transfer$10
Data Source(s)ACRIS
Effective Date of Data Source(s)7/14/2019
Comments on Market Listings
SFR_05_Listings: 07212014 Produced using ACI software, 800 234 8727 www.acciweb.com USAO 000384 | EFTA_00018294 | | :--- | :--- | This is a simple Markdown document with no headings, paragraphs, or tables. It contains just one line of text.